Showing posts with label autism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label autism. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 22, 2008

Big Brother Autism Slur

The key to the ratings machine for reality television lies in creating controversial situations and topics from the so-called unscripted actions of its main characters. Apparently, CBS got more than they bargained for when they chose to air the offensive comments of one of their reality show contestants. Adam Jasinski, a public relations manager for the United Autism Foundation and housemate on CBS’s show Big Brother 9, made comments about his work with children he calls “retards.” Jasinski claimed that he would use part of his winnings from the show—half a million dollars if he won first place—to “open a hair salon for kids with special needs, so the retards can get it together and get their hair done.” His housemate and partner in the game, Sheila, reacted with disapproval to his use of the word “retards” to which Jasinski responded with, “Disabled kids... I can call them whatever I want, OK. I bust my ass to help these special-needs children!”

Since the episode aired, CBS has been defended its use of the clip by saying that Jasinski’s words are his own, and are offensive, but the negative reaction of the other housemate showed this and therefore the clip was alright to air. Meanwhile, the show has lost advertising from home-improvement store Lowe’s and been leveled with complaints and criticism from other autism groups. On top of the show’s problems, this has drawn unwanted attention to the organization for which Jasinski claims to have worked.

Normally, I would shrug off the rude or offensive comments of a person on reality television; after all, they are there for the money and attention, so if they say something inappropriate, they can always go back and claim they just said it to get airtime. The amount of news that has been generated by this shocked me, mostly because people generally do not pay attention to what is said by the contestants on reality shows. This comment has created a stir among people who would not normally be discussing disability issues. I was happily surprised that Lowe’s pulled its advertising over the comment. Perhaps Lowe’s warned CBS about cleaning up its act after past incidents and this was the last straw. Then again, perhaps Lowe’s has realized that airing such content is CBS’s choice and such content is offensive and hurtful to more than just the people on the show.

Jasinki’s comment reminds me of the common line used by people in defense of racist comments: “But some of my best friends are….” Jasinski’s claim that he works with “special-needs” children does not help him defend his statement, if anything, it highlights the fact that he should know better than to use such language. Even his use of the term “special-needs” after the word “retards” further emphasizes the impropriety of word. The website for the organization Jasinski claims to work with often uses the term “special children.” This phrasing reminds me of Simi Linton’s discussion of the word “special.” While I disagreed with Linton’s argument against the use of the word “special” when I applied to education, I agree with the argument here because the words “special children” does come across as an attempt to be too politically correct and patronizing. Considering the group is geared specifically towards autism, why choose the words “special children?” Does the organization mean to be more inclusive by saying “special children” rather than saying “autistic children?” Perhaps this odd phrasing is what has Jasinski so confused about what he should say.

In the end, the comments made by this contestant are hurtful, but they have also proven to be useful. One blogger who commented on the controversy noted an increase in the visitation to her site and was grateful that something positive is coming from this otherwise distasteful situation. By writing and speaking about such offensive comments, people are reinforcing the idea that such comments are just that: offensive. Until the people using such language are made aware of its offensive nature, they will continue to use it without thinking. CBS may be guilty of trying to gain from one man’s ignorance, but they are not alone. At least now, with the disapproving actions of Lowe’s and other advertisers, they are allowing themselves and their contestants to be made examples of for any other show that may be thinking of airing such material. In addition to that, perhaps the inquiry into the organization will reveal whether or not it is worth the money and time that people have donated to it. Perhaps there could be a silver lining to this discussion after all.

Nightline: “'Underdiagnosed' Girls With Autism Struggle to Fit In”

Kaeda Sakai is an eight year-old girl with autism. Through her story, ABC’s Nightline program explores the issue of under diagnosed girls with autism. These girls face difficulties unknown to the average child and misunderstood by the average adult. Unlike their male peers, their symptoms are often explained away as simply being a part of what makes them female. They are “drama queens” or just socially inept when really they show signs of a much greater problem. By remaining undiagnosed, they miss the opportunity to receive the assistance that could help make their lives both easier and more enjoyable. This story tries to understand what makes “girl autism” so different, and how this affects the diagnosis of the girls and young women who live with it every day.

As a young woman, it is not hard for me to relate to difficulties that come with trying to decode the social workings of young girls. They are a group that can be both welcoming and off-putting at the same time, and they require acute attention to social cues and interactions. For a girl with autism not wired to interpret these cues, the effects must be socially devastating. For a young man to be anti-social might be seen as atypical but acceptable; for a young woman, it is unheard of. These young girls with autism are automatically at such a disadvantage with their peers that it must be devastating. A diagnosis could lead to some treatment and an understanding that could only help. On the other side, would the stigma of being a girl with autism only cause more trouble or other issues?

This video discusses the idea that many girls go undiagnosed because they are taught the social skills necessary to pass the diagnostic examinations. They are so developed in this area that only highly trained professionals can really recognize the signs of autism. Is this a form of passing even in young children? Are they taught at such a young age what is acceptable and not that they can hide their disability long enough to remain undiagnosed?

While it is not plausible to think that an eight year-old girl would purposefully try to fool anyone so that she could avoid being diagnosed, it is plausible to think that she has been trained to please adults and so she would try her hardest to do so. Kaeda’s case is special because her parents already had two autistic sons and were therefore better prepared to look for signs of autism in her; the average parent does not have the background knowledge needed to recognize the signs of such higher-functioning forms of autism.

Overall, I believe this article served its purpose. It managed to explain through one benchmark case just why young girls are underdiagnosed with autism. It did not try to understand why girls and boys behave differently with autism or the nature of autism at all. It even acknowledged that it did not answer the question of the difference between “girl autism” and “boy autism.” By doing so, the story was able to focus on what it really wanted to explain, and to tell the story well. The human aspect of this story was what counted, not the science behind it or anything else.

Austism Speaks

"You Asked, She Answered: Carly Fleischmann, 13, Talks to Our Views About Autism." ABC News Online. .


      The original article, presenting Carly and describing her incredible breakthrough, offers a chance for readers to post questions to Carly and have her answer them. Some of the questions are a little trite, and the original article probably has better responses than the question and answer follow-up. Asked what she wants people who do not understand autism to know, Carly responds:
Autism is hard because you want to act one way, but you can't
always do that. It's sad that sometimes people don't know that
sometimes I can't stop myself and they get mad at me. If I could
tell people one thing about autism it would be that I don't want
to be this way. But I am, so don't be mad. Be understanding. (abcnews.com)

In Carly’s own words, we have an opportunity to learn what it is like to be trapped inside a mind that won’t let you speak. She urges other therapists, in her question and answer article, to be patient with their charges and continue to encourage them. One reader asked, “What one thing do you think my autistic child would want me to know about him?” Carly, tellingly, answered, “I think he would want you to know that he knows more than you think he does. He is lucky to have nice parents” (abcnews.com). The answers provided by Carly give hope, no doubt, to countless parents of autistic children who cannot speak.

This is obviously a very heart-warming and encouraging story for many people, especially those with children who have autism and cannot speak. The fact that Carly can now show exactly how much she does know, and how much she picks up on is something everyone can appreciate. She shows that being unable to talk does not equate being unable to comprehend. For doctors and therapists, this opens up a world of opportunity. As Carly’s father explains, even professionals had labeled Carly as “moderately to severely cognitively impaired” (abcnews.com).