Showing posts with label article. Show all posts
Showing posts with label article. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 23, 2008

"Life With Anthony"

What would you do if you could know ahead of time that your child would have a life-long disability? Because Trisomy 21 can be detected during pregnancy, Lisa Spellman asks herself this very question in Margaret Renkyl’s article, “Life With Anthony.” According to this article, about 90% of pregnancies that test positive for Down Syndrome are aborted, but Lisa claims that if she had had the test and knew Anthony would have the disability, she would have carried the pregnancy to term anyway. What is most interesting about this article, however, is the words used to describe Anthony and his disability. The title, for example, gives a hint to the strange word-play to come, because the first thing that comes to mind after reading “Life With Anthony” is “Life Without Anthony.” In this way, I feel the young boy is equated with and identified by his disability. This kind of labeling can create stigma. The word choice of the section headers in the article will be discussed to show the pessimistic representation of disability.

The first section header is “Devastating news,” implying that Anthony’s initial diagnosis of Down Syndrome was a terrible tragedy; devastation is a term used to describe natural disasters, ruin, and death. It should not be used to describe the diagnosis of a little boy. The next section title is “Coming to terms,” which echoes the tragic quality assigned to Anthony’s diagnosis. When I think of the phrase “coming to terms,” I think of dealing with unavoidable crises. While Anthony’s disability came as a surprise, his family’s reaction is darkened by being described by this phrase. The final header in the article is “Fears and hopes.” By placing the word fear in front of hope, Down Syndrome is once again described in terms of devastation. One wonders what there is to be afraid of; Trisomy 21 is a disability, not a convicted kidnapper or murderer. The fear and stigma of Anthony’s disability seem to overshadow the fact that he can still have a good and productive life. This article is very telling of the stigma attached to disability, and it seems possible that these word choices were even accidental, or without such intention. Most of the headers in “Life With Anthony” clearly imply trepidation and doom for a little boy, and these headers are all assigning meaning to the label of disability that has been bestowed upon him.


article - http://www.cnn.com/2008/HEALTH/family/02/13/par.life.with.anthony/index.html?iref=newssearch

Tuesday, April 22, 2008

Austism Speaks

"You Asked, She Answered: Carly Fleischmann, 13, Talks to Our Views About Autism." ABC News Online. .


      The original article, presenting Carly and describing her incredible breakthrough, offers a chance for readers to post questions to Carly and have her answer them. Some of the questions are a little trite, and the original article probably has better responses than the question and answer follow-up. Asked what she wants people who do not understand autism to know, Carly responds:
Autism is hard because you want to act one way, but you can't
always do that. It's sad that sometimes people don't know that
sometimes I can't stop myself and they get mad at me. If I could
tell people one thing about autism it would be that I don't want
to be this way. But I am, so don't be mad. Be understanding. (abcnews.com)

In Carly’s own words, we have an opportunity to learn what it is like to be trapped inside a mind that won’t let you speak. She urges other therapists, in her question and answer article, to be patient with their charges and continue to encourage them. One reader asked, “What one thing do you think my autistic child would want me to know about him?” Carly, tellingly, answered, “I think he would want you to know that he knows more than you think he does. He is lucky to have nice parents” (abcnews.com). The answers provided by Carly give hope, no doubt, to countless parents of autistic children who cannot speak.

This is obviously a very heart-warming and encouraging story for many people, especially those with children who have autism and cannot speak. The fact that Carly can now show exactly how much she does know, and how much she picks up on is something everyone can appreciate. She shows that being unable to talk does not equate being unable to comprehend. For doctors and therapists, this opens up a world of opportunity. As Carly’s father explains, even professionals had labeled Carly as “moderately to severely cognitively impaired” (abcnews.com).

Artifact 1

“Doctors refuse mother’s request to remove disabled daughter’s womb ‘because of charity backlash’." The Daily Mail.

What is at stake here is a person’s right to choose, but in this case, the person cannot communicate what it is they choose. Like many in the disabled community, Katie Thorpe cannot express herself, and it is up to her caretaker, in this case, her mother Alison, to act on her behalf. However, charitable organizations, designed to represent the disabled, have stepped in and said that they better represent the wishes of the disabled. Personal rights should never be impeached, and an irreversible surgery to remove a woman’s womb would certainly be an impeachment of personal liberty, if, and only if, that person objected to the surgery. Is this a case of one person or one organization going too far? It would be easy to assume that Katie would not want to be subjected to the pain, discomfort, or humiliation of menstruation when her mother already must change Katie’s diapers (Katie is also incontinent). But what if some medical breakthrough is made in the next few years, while Katie is still of childbearing age? At this time, science is making leaps and bounds in progress, and a ‘cure’ for cerebral palsy could happen, even in the next twenty years or so. In that case, if Katie could be cured, the loss of her womb would be a devastating impeachment on her personal rights. However, if Katie is not cured, what then? Like many other disability rights issues, the choice of a patient who cannot communicate for herself cannot be properly understood. Then we must ask ourselves, who makes the final decision? Is it her mother, who raised her and takes care of her every day? Or the disability rights organizations, which know nothing of her personal life, but claim to know everything about her situation?